Why do I like DA revolvers but hate DAO pistols?

[S&Wshooter]

Originally Posted by k9870

Who says you can only own one smith and wesson?

Have revolvers carrying 5 shots, 6 shots, 7 shots, and 8 shots!

[Zulu Two Six]

Originally Posted by S&Wshooter

Have revolvers carrying 5 shots, 6 shots, 7 shots, and 8 shots!

smith and wesson 317?

[Yournamehere]

It's funny to see you guys with revolver boners talk about Smiths that are still in their catalog. I'd take my buddy's 70's workhorse Model 65 over anything you all have mentioned.

And it can't be that hard to get ahold of a 627. I've shot one (and I enjoy my Model 19 a whole lot more : D).

Oh yeah for the sake of being on topic, DAO pistols offer the safety of a double action trigger, with a consistent trigger pull. If the weight were light enough, it wouldn't be so bad, but usually they aren't, well over 10 pounds or so, and assuredly worse than a good revolver trigger, all kinds of creep everywhere. Then, you have the fact that you have to pull that nicely tuned double action revolver trigger 5, 6 or however many times to expend all of your shots, whereas you have to pull that DAO auto trigger 15 times, and it's going to be crappier every time. I can see it being really awesome if it's done right, but the thing is, it isn't really ever done right. SIG DAKs are probably the closest anything comes to a good DAO, since they are set at the good SIG DA trigger weight, but goddamn SIG triggers are creeptastic, I wouldn't be surprised if it were too.

[k9870]

I like k frames but want something that can conortably shoot magnums all day, and hold 8 shots.

[Yournamehere]

A 627 can't shoot Magnums all day, at least not forever. The one I used was broken, in fact. The single action sear was nearly nonexistent, making cocking the hammer almost impossible, and when it would stay at full cock, the slightest tap on the hammer would send it forward. Not only that, but the gun had developed a gap between the frame and the cylinder, which had gotten so big that the firing pin wouldn't always strike the primer fully, resulting in, what, misfires.

I'll be honest, I may be confusing the 627 with the 620 I shot in the same day, but in any case, the modern Smith did not survive it's usage without scars. On the other end, K frames have been reported with cracked forcing cones, but it'll take the hottest loads or handloads and repeated useage of them to cause that, and in shooting all those loads, your wrist and wallet are also going to hurt and your really just forcing overkill through your gun. Even mid power .357 loads are ballistically superior to a lot of autopistol loads, so unless you're trying to hunt big game with your small gun by feeding it gigantic loads like that, you're overdoing it severely (and even then, the forcing cone only may crack, it's not definite).

This probably isn't the rule, but it's what I've experienced and what I've come to find as some kind of truth. Granted an old Smith does not hold 8 shots, it's still just as, if not more serviceable than a modern one in my opinion, and in getting one, you have a new level of pride of ownership and a lot of money saved in your pocket to boot.

[k9870]

Id be happy with any smith honestly. The old blued guns without the lock look better to me but they all shoot just as well. Of course my opinions vary from internet consensus, kinda like how I hate colt.

[Jcordell]

I was twelve in 1980 when my father began my firearms education. He was an Idaho State Trooper so he naturally used his duty revolver as one of the weapons he introduced to me.

It was a S&W Model 65 with a 4" barrel. I fired 38 special full wadcutters. Probably 148 grain.

I also started with my dad's S&W Model 36 which was by my request. I had loved that little revolver since he had gotten it some five years earlier. Guess I watched too many detective movies. I still like that little revolver. So much that I now own my own.

Last of all was his S&W K-22 Target Masterpiece.

When it finally came time for me to own my own handgun it was a Colt Trooper Mk III with a 6" barrel. Christmas 1983.

Once in a great while I would shoot dad's Colt Commander or his Walther PPK. But 45 acp and .380 was expensive. 38 wadcutter loads were provided by ISP to the troopers for practice. It was plentiful.

Cut my teeth on revolvers. Then as the years went by I became infatuated with semi-autos. Revolvers were clunky and old-fashioned. I wanted Sig, Beretta, Browning, Glock and H&K.

I spent many years in the U.S. Army and was totally happy with all the automatics and semi-automatics. Entered into my law enforcement career in 2000 and carried a Sig Sauer P220 (45acp). Didn't miss revolvers. However my Colt Trooper was still in my safe. Hadn't shot it in years, but it was still there.

Fast forward to November 2003. I was at a local gunshow. For some reason ,that I still don't understand, a S&W M28 Highway Patrolman w/6" barrel caught my eye. I don't know why. I found myself looking at it and I began to remember those first shooting lessons with dad in the summer of 1980. Suddenly I knew that I had to have it. Didn't even haggle over the price. $350.00 and I walked out with a revolver. After twenty years I had bought a revolver.

I now have ten revolvers. The Sig P220 went for a trade to get one of those revolvers now in my safe and I now carry a Glock 19 as my duty sidearm.

I haven't quit semi-autos. I own four of them (G19,G26, Colt M1908 Hammerless and a Browning Buckmark) and I like them. However revolvers speak to me of a different time and place. In the practical sense they've helped me become a better shooter. Old fashioned or not I like them. Both revolvers and semi-autos have their strengths and weaknesses. Neither reigns supreme over the other.

[S&Wshooter]

Originally Posted by Yournamehere

And it can't be that hard to get ahold of a 627. I've shot one (and I enjoy my Model 19 a whole lot more : D).

It'd be pretty difficult to get one in the exact configuration k9870 specified unless you visit a loan shark to get the amount of cash you would need to special order it

[k9870]

Originally Posted by S&Wshooter

It'd be pretty difficult to get one in the exact configuration k9870 specified unless you visit a loan shark to get the amount of cash you would need to special order it

Just buy the 627, may need to order one if not in store. then send it to clark custom guns down in louisiana for work. Im not expecting a super revovler from the factory.

I see semis as being a much more useful self defense tool, but when it comes to shooting fun, I want some of each.

[funkychinaman]

I prefer revolvers for the same reason I like DA/SA autos, I like having a choice. I don't think I can ever get a DAO revolver. (I was looking at a Ruger LCR though, because it was light and looked cool, but the guy wouldn't let me test the trigger pull.) I remember I was looking for a concealed carry gun, and it came down to a Kel Tec PF9 or a snub revolver, and I went with the revolver, because I wanted something I can enjoy shooting at the range as well. I would like to work on my DA shooting though.