Splitting the S&W Revolver Pages?

[zackmann08]

I think having a page for each frame is a bad idea. It will result in enormous pages of vastly different guns. That being said, adding a notation of the frame type to the Smith & Wesson page is a fantastic idea. One that I am tempted to run with...

[predator20]

The Model 629 should definitely be split from the 29 page. Not sure why it didn't it's own page to begin with. Model 586/686, 19/66 each have their own.

A category could be created for each frame size, so they can be grouped together that way. Having the frame size listed on the S&W page may help some.

[Ben41]

I would agree with the splitting as long as there are proper links from the stainless version to the original.

[zackmann08]

Another one that needs some attention is the Model 637 which appears on two different pages. (Smith & Wesson Model 637 & Smith & Wesson Model 37 Airweight / 637 Airweight)

[zackmann08]

Did we come to a conclusion on this?

[Jcordell]

Originally Posted by zackmann08

Did we come to a conclusion on this?

Noyes. I think the way it's been done with the frame size being listed on the manufacturer page is the best way to go. But other than that I think the original idea is the way to go.

[MT2008]

As long as we're consistent, I don't care. I would rather merge than separate stainless from blued versions, but I'll defer to majority opinion on this.