Should I buy these?

[ersoz]

Here's some better pictures:






I don't care much for these revolvers.

[S&Wshooter]

I'd buy them, but that's just me

[Nyles]

The Broomhandle has been refinished for sure, so it's definately post-factory, and it doesn't look all that old to me. In fact for me the only two guns there that pass the initial "sniff test" with me are the St Etienne (in 8mm, incidentally, not 6.35) and the Webley, and I'd want a closer look at either. I'd be interested in the unknown revolver as a curiosity if I could get it cheap enough, but I'm starting to suspect it's a blacksmith made gun and I definately wouldn't shoot it. My gut reaction here is pass.

[ersoz]

Originally Posted by Nyles

The Broomhandle has been refinished for sure, so it's definately post-factory, and it doesn't look all that old to me. In fact for me the only two guns there that pass the initial "sniff test" with me are the St Etienne (in 8mm, incidentally, not 6.35) and the Webley, and I'd want a closer look at either. I'd be interested in the unknown revolver as a curiosity if I could get it cheap enough, but I'm starting to suspect it's a blacksmith made gun and I definately wouldn't shoot it. My gut reaction here is pass.

My thought exactly.
I'll wait until I find that very special pistol.