That's a little on the high side, especially considering it was a display model that was broken, but it doesn't matter if you keep it forever.

did it come with goodies like extra mags, magloader, case?

Even if it came with all the bells and whistles, you just got price gouged

depends on the goodies, p99 mags are like 50 bucks a piece, if he got a few extras may be g\good.

Why are the mags so expensive? The highest I ever see handgun mags go is ~$40, and that's for really hard to find stuff

only walther makes mags for it, and no big makers like mecgar, plus the walther is not as common as bigger brands, supply and demand.

That makes sense

What i dont get is most companies use mecgar as the factory mag, bur always use the smaller capacity mag, mecgar makes mags usually 2 rounds more than is given with a flush fit. so beretta and sig make 15 round 9mm mags, and mecgar makes 17 rounds same size, then you got the browning, `3 standard, 15 mecgar, id personally only use mecgar for guns like that,

It came with an extra mag and a case. Although Bass Pro Shops is somewhat of a tourist trap.

yeah, you were ripped of, they usually go 550-650 depending on model.