I put back up the ones that are on the bubble:
Ultimate Weapons DEA Weaponology Top Gear Top Shot Top Sniper 2 Dallas SWAT Situation Critical Mythbusters Deadliest Warriors (Seasons 1 & 2) Any other ones? |
Quote:
|
Ultimate Weapons - I guess stay, but I don't really care for ones that tell you what the weapon is.
DEA - nay Weaponology - nay Top Gear - I guess stay Top Shot - stay, even though they tell you the weapon used. It's a well built page. Top Sniper 2 - a lot of screencaps, but no descriptions, nay Dallas SWAT - nay Situation Critical - stay, it's a documentary, but isn't it more or less reenactments? Mythbusters -stay Deadliest Warriors (Seasons 1 & 2) -stay The way I see it, if it's already been built and has some effort it should stay. But no more new documentary pages. |
Quote:
If some page is suggested for deletion, it should be in the Discussion page. That way people can put input forth and Mods can review and make a cool headed decision. I hate those reality TV / Documentaries myself (and I was always against them) because (a) usually they do a show on the gun itself, so identifying it is pointless and (b) documenting what REAL COPS use (in shows like Dallas SWAT / DEA / etc.) falls outside of the scope of IMFDB because no movie armorer provided the weapon. We would just be reiterating what is 'regulation' for that department to really carry (c) Documentaries open the door to all sorts of irrelevant entries. We once had a CBS News show on Operation Enduring Freedom (invasion of Afghanistan 2002). My thought was 'who cares?' All they did was use existing news footage of the warring parties. We would soon be putting up pages for ABC World News Tonight! if that continued. That page was quickly deleted. Television was supposed to be TELEVISION SHOWS. Not reality TV or news or documentaries. Those shows depict real life and open the doors to too many barely relevant entries. That being said, we should VOTE on which ones stay. But seriously there was supposed to be a MORATORIUM on new reality TV/documentaries shows. What happened to that? |
How much input does Chris Bunni actually give as far as these kinds of decisions go?
|
Quote:
http://i142.photobucket.com/albums/r...enateBunni.jpg |
Quote:
Actually, I think I should leave it to someone better than me to explain it: Clicky! |
RE - the new category. Me gusta mucho. Definitely something to use more in the future. And I like how it links to the rules, too.
Quote:
|
Quote:
He made no fans here, even though his point may be good, he's such a douche that I couldn't get to whatever point he was trying to make.... |
I would like to know what the mods think of this page:
http://www.imfdb.org/index.php/War_Briefing%2C_The It falls under the documentary category since it is an episode of PBS Frontline, but seems to have slipped under the radar since no one has mentioned it so far. Also look at these pages: http://www.imfdb.org/index.php/Manhu...ive_Task_Force http://www.imfdb.org/index.php/Real_Vice_Cops_Uncut These three pages, along with DEA and Dallas SWAT, were all created by Choi117. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 08:29 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.